Difference between revisions of "Rail: Interlocking Ties"

From MDOT Policy Manual
Jump to: navigation, search
 
(2 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 7: Line 7:
 
| colspan="3" |
 
| colspan="3" |
 
=Primary Guidance=
 
=Primary Guidance=
*Concrete ties are preferred over timber ties.
+
:* The selection of the type of ties should consider present-term and long-term advantages and disadvantages of available alternatives
*Prepare cost benefit analysis when evaluating timber ties versus concrete ties.
+
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
| colspan="3" |
 
| colspan="3" |
 
 
=Discussion=
 
=Discussion=
Concrete ties are preferred.  The selection of timber ties vs. concrete ties should be determined by a cost-benefit analysis using current price data considering long-term replacement, operations and maintenance cost to determine the most cost effective design.  Timber ties will generally have a lower initial capital cost, but will require higher maintenance and replacement costs than concrete ties.  Environmental requirements including handling and special measures for eventual disposal of creosoted timber ties need to be considered as part of analysis.
+
:* Concrete ties are preferred.  The selection of timber ties vs. concrete ties should be determined by a cost-benefit analysis using current price data considering long-term replacement, operations and maintenance cost to determine the most cost effective design.  Timber ties will generally have a lower initial capital cost, but will require higher maintenance and replacement costs than concrete ties.  Environmental requirements including handling and special measures for eventual disposal of creosoted timber ties need to be considered as part of analysis.
  
  [[Category:Practical Design]][[Category:Practical Design Guidance]][[Category:Secure]]
+
  [[Category:Practical Design]][[Category:Practical Design Guidance]]
  
 
=See Also=
 
=See Also=
*[[Rail: Interlocking|Interlocking]]
+
:* [[Rail: Interlocking|Interlocking]]
*[[Practical_Design_Implementation_Guidance:_Rail|Rail]]
+
:* [[Practical_Design_Implementation_Guidance:_Rail|Rail]]
*[[Practical Design Implementation Guidance|Practical Design Implementation Guidance]]
+
:* [[Practical Design Implementation Guidance|Practical Design Implementation Guidance]]

Latest revision as of 16:10, 26 May 2017

Interlocking Tie

Primary Guidance

  • The selection of the type of ties should consider present-term and long-term advantages and disadvantages of available alternatives

Discussion

  • Concrete ties are preferred. The selection of timber ties vs. concrete ties should be determined by a cost-benefit analysis using current price data considering long-term replacement, operations and maintenance cost to determine the most cost effective design. Timber ties will generally have a lower initial capital cost, but will require higher maintenance and replacement costs than concrete ties. Environmental requirements including handling and special measures for eventual disposal of creosoted timber ties need to be considered as part of analysis.

See Also